Best and Worst Nootropics According to Reddit 2024. And, Can you Trust Redditors?

Updated on March 3, 2024
 by — reviewed by Jason Williams, PhD (Contributor: George Collins / Editor: Yoko Hill)
Analyzing the contrasting opinions on nootropics as discussed by Reddit users.

We’ve scoured the depths of Reddit, the go-to hotspot for genuine user experiences, to compile a list of the top nootropics that have been tried, tested and praised by avid users and experts alike.

Reddit for health-related topics became especially popular during COVID-19 where Google and other tech firms began a government-mandated and coordinated effort to clamp down on “misinformation,” with the unfortunate side-effect of filtering out all but the top publishers such as Mayo Clinic and Healthline when it came to health and medical-related queries. Since then, first-hand and anecdotal information about most supplements, medical issues and healthcare have all but disappeared from the search results pages. Thus, we turn to Reddit.

We’ve excluded obvious the “bro science” Redditor’s posts that you can’t trust (there’s a lot of them) and tried to only use the reviews that seemed genuine, and most importantly long-term with follow-ups and active engagement from the OP. We’ll focus on the best products they’ve used first and follow-up with another post on Reddit’s consensus of the worst nootropics and the ones to avoid.

You can use this resource for aggregated Reddit-generated nootropic recommendations and reports so you can make informed choices in your quest for optimal cognitive performance.

What Nootropics Redditors Found the Best Overall

  • Feedamind — Reddit’s favorite nootropic stack for cognitive improvement
  • Mind Lab Pro — Redditors top choice for overall brain health
  • NooCube — Top-rated for stress and anxiety by many users
  • Brain Pill — Great for improving overall brain cell health
  • Hunter Focus — Best for enhancing mental focus
  • Alpha Brain — Best to help increase concentration and focus
  • Aniracetam — Most popular racetam on Reddit

How to Choose According to Reddit?

Selecting the ideal nootropics based on Reddit suggestions requires careful consideration of several factors to ensure both efficacy and safety. As we all know, Reddit, like any anonymous Internet forum, can’t be relied on too heavily. What some Reddit bros may say is “the bomb” may not always be true. It’s vital to do your due diligence when buying something to put in your body. For example:

FactorDescriptionWhy It’s Important
Ingredient TransparencyClarity on what the nootropic contains.Ensures you know exactly what you’re consuming and can research the effects and safety of each component.
Scientific BackingEvidence of effectiveness and safety from scientific studies.Provides reassurance that the nootropic has been tested and proven to work, reducing the risk of ineffective or harmful products.
User ExperiencesAnecdotal evidence from actual users.Offers insights into real-world effects and potential side effects that may not be evident from scientific studies alone.
Value for MoneyCost in relation to benefits and quantity.Ensures you are getting a product worth your investment without overpaying for hype.
Side Effect ProfileKnown adverse effects and contraindications.Helps you weigh the benefits against potential risks and manage your overall health.
  • Ingredient Transparency: Knowing the exact ingredients and their dosages is critical, as this allows you to research each substance’s safety and efficacy. This transparency also helps identify potential allergens or substances that may interact with other medications you’re taking.
  • Scientific Backing: A nootropic backed by scientific evidence provides a level of credibility and assurance. Peer-reviewed studies and clinical trials are strong indicators that a nootropic is likely to be both effective and safe.
  • User Experiences: Anecdotes from other users, especially those within the Reddit community, can offer a preview of what to expect. While not as reliable as scientific data, they can provide practical insights into the usage and effects of the nootropic.
  • Value for Money: Compare the cost against the number of servings, the quality of ingredients, and the reputation of the brand. A higher price doesn’t always equate to a better product, so it’s important to find a balance.
  • Side Effect Profile: Understanding the potential side effects is vital for any supplement. Even if a nootropic is effective, significant adverse effects might make it unsuitable for you, particularly if you have certain health conditions or sensitivities.

What Reddit Users Liked the Most in 2024

Our in-depth data analysis of Reddit threads revealed that the most highly recommended products on Reddit are:

1. Feedamind

Feedamind has gained considerable attention and praise on Reddit, with many users sharing their positive experiences with this all-natural nootropic supplement. Designed to improve cognitive performance and optimize overall brain function, Feedamind’s formula consists of 16 carefully selected ingredients, all well-known for their brain-boosting properties. Users on Reddit have found that this powerful blend not only unlocks their mind’s full potential but also enables them to perform tasks at peak cognitive efficiency.

Feedamind is highly effective at enhancing focus, memory, and hand-eye coordination, with noticeable improvements observable within the first few days of use.(1)(2) Moreover, users report experiencing better multitasking abilities and reduced mental fatigue when taking the supplement. Such benefits are particularly useful for students, professionals, and anyone looking to level up their mental game in a world that demands constant attention and performance.

One reason why Feedamind is highly respected in the Reddit community is its natural formulation, which avoids harsh stimulants. The supplement includes powerful ingredients like Pterostilbene, Oat Straw Extract, and Marigold Flower Extract, all of which have been scientifically proven to promote cognitive function and enhance overall brain health. When combined, these ingredients work synergistically to deliver even more pronounced effects.


  • Proven to enhance brain function
  • Improves blood flow to the brain
  • Works well against memory loss
  • Improves central nervous system health


  • May cause sleeping difficulty in some users
  • May cause some users to feel jittery or anxious

While the benefits of Feedamind can be seen relatively quickly, Reddit users emphasize the importance of consistent and long-term supplementation to achieve the best results. This allows the brain to receive the sustained benefits of these natural ingredients, leading to ongoing improvements in cognitive performance. With such glowing recommendations and experiences shared by Reddit users, it’s no wonder that Feedamind has earned a top spot on the list of best nootropics on the platform.

2. Mind Lab Pro

One of the top nootropics recommended by Reddit users is Mind Lab Pro. This popular cognitive enhancer has garnered a strong following on the platform, with many users praising its effectiveness in boosting mental performance. Mind Lab Pro is a comprehensive and well-formulated nootropic supplement that aims to improve various aspects of cognitive functioning, such as memory, focus, and processing speed.

With Mind Lab Pro’s impressive blend of 11 clinically backed ingredients, this supplement has been designed to work synergistically to optimize overall brain health. Many Reddit users have shared their positive experiences with it, reporting noticeable improvements in their day-to-day productivity and cognitive performance.

One of the key selling points of Mind Lab Pro is its natural and safe formulation. This nootropic supplement is free from artificial additives, allergens, and stimulants, making it suitable for long-term use. Reddit users have emphasized the importance of sticking to the recommended dosage to achieve the best results and avoid potential side effects.

Another aspect that makes Mind Lab Pro stand out among other nootropics is its commitment to high-quality, clean manufacturing. The company ensures that their products undergo third-party testing for purity and potency, further solidifying the trust of their users. This rigorous quality control, combined with the positive experiences shared by Reddit users, makes Mind Lab Pro a top recommendation for enhancing cognitive performance.


  • Increases healthy blood flow into the brain
  • Improves brain function and increases alertness, focus, mood, and reduces stress
  • Helps produce alpha waves to boost problem-solving skills
  • Stimulates the production of dopamine, a neurotransmitter


  • May not work for every individual depending on age and diet
  • May interact with other medications or supplements

In conclusion, Mind Lab Pro has earned its place as one of the top smart drugs commonly loved by Reddit. With a unique blend of ingredients, commitment to quality, and countless positive testimonials from satisfied users, it is no wonder that many turn to this supplement for a noticeable cognitive boost.

3. NooCube

NooCube is a highly praised nootropic supplement by many people, being recognized as one of the most effective cognitive enhancers available on the market. Many Reddit users have found NooCube to be an excellent supplement for boosting brain function. Developed by leading neuroscientists and formulated with a blend of natural ingredients, NooCube aims to safely enhance cognitive functioning without causing addiction.

There are various benefits to taking NooCube, including improved focus, memory, processing speed, and motivation.(3)(4) Many people have also found that this nootropic effectively helps them get into the “zone” for peak productivity. By fostering a state of acute focus and allowing users to effortlessly enter a flow state when working on tasks, NooCube has gained a loyal following among Reddit’s community. NooCube’s ability to clear mental obstacles has been praised by many, as it allows individuals to regain focus and mental clarity during crucial moments.


  • Jump-starts your brain and improves cognitive performance
    Works quickly and has high potency
  • Helps reach peak mental performance
  • Helps to improve neuron health and achieve sharp focus


  • Can take up to three months to become noticeable

Despite its popularity, there have been concerns raised about the product containing synthetic ingredients in addition to natural ones. However, the majority of Reddit users seem to be in consensus that the benefits of NooCube outweigh its drawbacks. With its proven track record for enhancing cognitive function and overall brain performance, it is clear why NooCube is a top choice in this category of products on Reddit.

4. Brain Pill

Among the top nootropics recommended by Reddit users is Brain Pill, a popular supplement designed to enhance cognitive function and improve overall brain health. Known for its natural and powerful ingredients, this product has gained considerable attention on Reddit for its impressive results and positive user feedback.

Brain Pill is formulated with a blend of vitamins, amino acids, and herbal extracts, all known to support and boost various aspects of cognitive functioning. Some key components in the supplement include Cognizin, Synapsa, Huperzine A, Vinpocetine, and Ginkgo Biloba. These ingredients work together to improve memory, enhance focus and concentration, increase mental agility, and protect the brain from age-related decline and oxidative damage.(5)(6)

Users report that the effects of Brain Pill are felt within a relatively short period, often within a week or two of regular use. They claim to experience increased mental clarity, improved memory recall, and a heightened sense of focus. The natural ingredients in Brain Pill ensure that users experience these benefits without unwanted side effects or overstimulation, making it suitable for long-term use.


  • Improves brain function
  • Increases memory and concentration
  • Increases clarity and sharpness
  • Helps slow age-related cognitive decline


  • Long-term effects are not well established

In conclusion, Brain Pill stands out amongst the nootropics recommended by many users, thanks to its carefully selected, high-quality ingredients, numerous positive user reports, and the backing of a reputable company. Whether you’re an overworked professional seeking better focus and mental agility or simply looking to protect and improve your cognitive function over time, Brain Pill is a highly recommended nootropic supplement to consider.

5. Hunter Focus

Hunter Focus is a popular choice among Reddit users for its ability to sharpen cognitive abilities and boost mental clarity. It is effectively among the top supplements for focus and increased productivity. This nootropic offers multiple benefits, including enhanced concentration, memory recall, and mental endurance. Moreover, it has gained a favorable reputation on Reddit for its natural ingredients and effective results.

One of the key factors that make Hunter Focus a favorite among users is its carefully selected blend of high-quality ingredients. The formula contains eleven natural ingredients, such as Lion’s Mane Mushroom, Ashwagandha, and Rhodiola Rosea, which have demonstrated benefits in improving cognitive function and combating stress.(7)(8)

Furthermore, Hunter Focus ensures optimal efficacy by recommending a daily dose of six capsules, which can be easily incorporated into a regular routine. As a result, users can experience the benefits without facing major disruptions in their daily schedules.


  • Increases healthy blood flow into the brain
  • Boosts productivity by stimulating alpha brain waves
  • Has significant effect on motivation and emotional stability
  • Able to increase memory retention


  • Not recommended for pregnant women
  • May cause some minor side effects in some users

In conclusion, Hunter Focus is highly recommended by Reddit users for its natural formulation, effectiveness, and transparency. Its blend of potent ingredients, user-friendly dosage, and positive user experiences makes it one of the best smart drugs on Reddit. If you’re looking for a reliable, natural, and powerful cognitive booster, then Hunter Focus might be the perfect choice for you.

6. Alpha Brain

Alpha Brain has gained a solid reputation among users for its cognitive-enhancing properties. Developed by the well-known American company Onnit Labs, Alpha Brain boasts a blend of natural ingredients designed to improve memory, focus, and overall cognitive function. Many Redditors have shared their positive experiences with Alpha Brain, mentioning increased mental clarity and productivity after using the supplement.

One of the key features that makes Alpha Brain stand out is its list of clinically tested ingredients that work together to optimize brain performance. Some notable ingredients include L-Leucine, Bacopa Monnieri, Huperzine A, and L-Theanine, which have all been proven to enhance cognition and promote relaxation.(9)(10) Alpha Brain is effective in combating brain fog and improving multitasking abilities.

Though Alpha Brain has received praise for its effectiveness, it’s essential to consider individual reactions to the supplement. Some users on Reddit have reported mild side effects like headaches and sleep disturbances. However, these instances are relatively rare, and most users seem to enjoy the benefits of Alpha Brain without any adverse effects. To minimize the risk of side effects, it’s recommended to start with the lowest recommended dosage and gradually increase it if needed.


  • Helps to enhance brain processing speed
  • Helps reduce anxiety and stress and increase motivation
  • Boosts cognitive function and overall brain health


  • May interact with certain medication
  • Not recommended for children and nursing women

Another advantage of Alpha Brain is that it’s available over-the-counter, making it easily accessible for those looking to improve their cognitive performance. However, it’s essential to keep in mind that individual experiences with nootropics can vary widely, so it’s important to be cautious and do thorough research before trying any new supplement. Ultimately, Alpha Brain has earned its place among the best of the best on Reddit due to its natural ingredients, effectiveness, and favorable user reviews.

7. Aniracetam

Aniracetam is a popular nootropic supplement that has gained significant attention on Reddit. Users and reports suggest that this supplement offers a wide range of cognitive benefits, including enhanced memory, focus, and mental clarity.(11) This synthetic compound is part of the racetam family, which consists of numerous cognitive-enhancing supplements. Aniracetam, in particular, is considered to be more potent than its predecessor, Piracetam. It is fat-soluble, allowing it to be easily absorbed in the brain, and works by stimulating the release of neurotransmitters such as dopamine and serotonin, resulting in improved mood and cognitive function.(12)

Many Reddit users state that this supplement has helped them improve their focus and cognitive abilities, making it a valuable tool for students and individuals looking to enhance their performance at work or in daily tasks.

However, it is important to note that the effects of Aniracetam can vary between individuals. Some users may not experience significant benefits from it or may require a higher dosage for desired results. As with any supplement, it is recommended to consult with a healthcare professional before incorporating Aniracetam into your routine.

One downside to Aniracetam that is often mentioned on Reddit is its relatively short half-life, meaning its effects can be short-lived. To counteract this issue, some users suggest taking Aniracetam multiple times throughout the day in smaller doses, while others combine it with other nootropics to create a synergistic effect.


  • Helps to alleviate mental health issues
  • Increases focus and attention span
  • Helps with anxiety and depression


  • May cause side effects such as headaches and nausea

Overall, Aniracetam is considered one of the best nootropics available by Reddit users and reports, due to its wide range of cognitive benefits and relatively mild side effects. Its potential in improving mental performance, focus, and anxiety levels make it an appealing choice for those looking to optimize their cognitive abilities.

First Hand Experience is the Idea Behind Reddit

Reddit, an online platform for sharing news, information, and opinions, hosts numerous discussions and debates on the topic of nootropics. A wide range of users share their personal (assumingly) first-hand experiences, providing valuable insights into the effectiveness of these substances.

Reddit discussions on nootropics generally revolve around the chemical compositions, mechanisms of action, and side effects associated with using these substances. Users on the platform often exchange ideas about specific smart drugs, offering information on dosage, potential benefits, and drawbacks. This community-driven platform can serve as a valuable resource for individuals interested in exploring nootropic options.

It is important to note, however, that while some Reddit users might be well-informed on the topic, not all information shared on the platform is verified or supported by scientific evidence. Therefore, it is crucial for interested individuals to consult with a healthcare professional and seek reliable sources of information before incorporating nootropics into their daily routine.

By sharing their experiences and insights, Reddit users contribute to a growing knowledge base of nootropics and their effects on cognitive performance. In some cases, users report positive results and attribute improvements in memory, focus, and mental clarity to their nootropic use. Nonetheless, it is essential to exercise caution and thoroughly research these substances before considering them as a means to enhance cognitive abilities.

Before buying anything, it’s essential to evaluate several factors. These considerations will help ensure that your choice aligns with your health goals and lifestyle.

1. Compatibility with Health Conditions

Consider any pre-existing health issues you may have and how a nootropic could interact with them. For instance, certain supplements might exacerbate anxiety or interact negatively with medications for blood pressure.

2. Long-Term Sustainability

Evaluate whether a nootropic is suitable for long-term use, as some may be intended for short-term cognitive boosts rather than ongoing supplementation.

Ensure that the nootropic is legal in your region and aligns with any personal or professional ethical standards, such as avoiding banned substances in competitive sports.

4. Company Reputation and Product Quality

Research the brand’s reputation and the quality of their products. A trustworthy company should have transparent manufacturing processes and third-party testing.

5. Personal Goals and Expectations

Reflect on what you aim to achieve with nootropics and set realistic expectations about the outcomes.

How We Selected Reddit’s Favorite Supplements

We employed a comprehensive review process to identify the best of the best on Reddit. Our assessment considered factors such as Reddit users’ recommendations, ingredients, scientific evidence, dosage, safety, product transparency, manufacturing process, real-life experiences, price, and value. By examining these elements, we were able to present readers with an accurate and reliable collection of the most highly-regarded nootropics on Reddit.

Reddit Users’ Recommendations

We scoured numerous Reddit threads, considering upvotes and comments to gauge the popularity and efficacy of nootropics mentioned by the Reddit community.


We inspected each nootropic’s ingredients, emphasizing well-researched, safe, and high-quality substances known to boost cognitive performance.

Scientific Evidence

We consulted peer-reviewed studies and meta-analyses to determine the effectiveness of key ingredients within each nootropic blend.


We evaluated appropriate dosages and ingredient proportions to ensure they align with research-backed recommendations for optimal potency.


We confirmed the safety of each ingredient, accounting for possible side effects and interactions, as well as compliance with regulatory guidelines. Prioritizing FDA-approved components is crucial.

Product Transparency

We valued detailed information on ingredients, including their sources and concentrations, enabling Reddit users to make informed decisions about nootropic options.

Manufacturing Process

We investigated manufacturing standards, prioritizing nootropics produced in certified facilities and adhering to Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP).

Real-Life Experiences

We analyzed Reddit users’ first-hand accounts, focusing on experiences that emphasize cognitive enhancements and noticeable improvements in mental function.


We compared the prices of various nootropics, ensuring they were reasonable and consistent with their quality and effectiveness.


Lastly, we evaluated the overall value of each nootropic, taking into account the balance between price, quality, and effectiveness to guarantee the best return on investment for Reddit users.

By analyzing Reddit users’ experiences and reports, we have identified several popular nootropics that have shown promise in improving brain function and enhancing cognitive performance.

The top seven recommended smart drugs on Reddit include Feedamind, Mind Lab Pro, NooCube, Brain Pill, Hunter Focus, Alpha Brain, and Aniracetam. These supplements have been praised for their ability to improve focus, enhance memory, boost cognitive abilities, and reduce anxiety and stress. Many users have reported positive experiences, attributing increased productivity, sharper mental clarity, and improved overall brain health to these nootropics.

While Reddit serves as a valuable platform for sharing user experiences, it is essential to approach information with caution and consult with healthcare professionals before incorporating any nootropics into one’s routine. Scientific evidence and verified sources should be sought to ensure informed decision-making.


Are there any risks associated with using these nootropics?

While many nootropics have shown effectiveness, users may sometimes experiment with untested research chemicals or synthetic substances. These chemicals can pose potential risks and adverse effects, so it’s best to stick to natural, well-researched supplements.

What precautions should I take before trying a nootropic?

Consult a healthcare professional, research the nootropic’s safety and efficacy, assess your individual health condition, and start with a low dosage to minimize potential side effects. Just because someone on Reddit liked something, doesn’t mean you will.

How can I identify and avoid potentially harmful nootropics?

Research thoroughly before trying any nootropic, pay attention to reported side effects, avoid buying products from unknown sources, and follow the advice of healthcare professionals, as well as skilled and experienced Reddit users.

How can I determine the appropriate dosages for nootropics based on Reddit recommendations?

Reddit users’ experiences may help you determine general dosage guidelines. However, it’s best to consult a healthcare professional, refer to manufacturer recommendations, research scientific literature, and consider your unique health condition.

Sources, Studies, and Scientific Research
  1. Hojnik, Maša, Mojca Škerget, and Željko Knez. “Extraction of lutein from Marigold flower petals–Experimental kinetics and modelling.” LWT-Food Science and Technology 41.10 (2008). ↩
  2. McCormack, Denise, and David McFadden. “A review of pterostilbene antioxidant activity and disease modification.” Oxidative medicine and cellular longevity 2013 (2013). ↩
  3. Sandoval, M., et al. “Anti-inflammatory and antioxidant activities of cat’s claw (Uncaria tomentosa and Uncaria guianensis) are independent of their alkaloid content.” Phytomedicine 9.4 (2002): 325-337. ↩
  4. Ferreira, Ana, et al. “Huperzine A from Huperzia serrata: a review of its sources, chemistry, pharmacology and toxicology.” Phytochemistry reviews 15 (2016): 51-85. ↩
  5. Szatmári, Szabolcs, Peter Whitehouse, and Cochrane Dementia and Cognitive Improvement Group. “Vinpocetine for cognitive impairment and dementia.” Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2010.1 (1996). ↩
  6. Aguiar, Sebastian, and Thomas Borowski. “Neuropharmacological review of the nootropic herb Bacopa monnieri.” Rejuvenation research 16.4 (2013): 313-326. ↩
  7. Panossian, Alexander, G. Wikman, and Jerome Sarris. “Rosenroot (Rhodiola rosea): traditional use, chemical composition, pharmacology and clinical efficacy.” Phytomedicine 17.7 (2010): 481-493. ↩
  8. Zahiruddin, Sultan, et al. “Ashwagandha in brain disorders: A review of recent developments.” Journal of ethnopharmacology 257 (2020): 112876. ↩
  9. Lee, Song Hee, et al. “Late treatment with choline alfoscerate (l-alpha glycerylphosphorylcholine, α-GPC) increases hippocampal neurogenesis and provides protection against seizure-induced neuronal death and cognitive impairment.” Brain research 1654 (2017): 66-76. ↩
  10. Zanchi, Nelo E., Humberto Nicastro, and Antonio H. Lancha. “Potential antiproteolytic effects of L-leucine: observations of in vitro and in vivo studies.” Nutrition & metabolism 5.1 (2008): 1-7. ↩
  11. Bartolini, L., F. Casamenti, and G. Pepeu. “Aniracetam restores object recognition impaired by age, scopolamine, and nucleus basalis lesions.” Pharmacology Biochemistry and Behavior 53.2 (1996): 277-283. ↩
  12. Lee, C. Rhoda, and Paul Benfield. “Aniracetam: an overview of its pharmacodynamic and pharmacokinetic properties, and a review of its therapeutic potential in senile cognitive disorders.” Drugs & aging 4 (1994): 257-273. ↩